Guide
How to build a vacation rental comp set
By Andrew Kitchell, CEO & Founder
Build your comp set from the homes a guest would book instead of yours, and keep more of them than most guides suggest. Our research on comparable sets found it's better to price against a larger set of homes that might compete with yours than a small set of homes that certainly do, with a looser match where homes are few.
On this page
What a vacation rental competitive set is
A competitive set, or comp set, is the group of listings you compare your home with when you set its prices and judge how it's doing. It's only useful if it holds the homes your guests actually weigh against yours.
Our research names four checks a guest runs before booking, and they make a good test for every home you add:
- Unit: do the bedrooms, beds and amenities meet what the guest needs?
- Host: does the host meet their bar for trust and quality?
- Price: does the price fit their budget?
- Location: does the location fit their plans?
A home that fails one of these for your guests doesn't belong in the set, however close it sits. A home a few miles out that passes all four does.
How many listings belong in a vacation rental comp set
There is no fixed number. Most guides say 5 to 15 homes, or 5 to 10, picked because they look most like yours. That's plenty for keeping an eye on a few rivals by name, and too few to price against.
In our research, the size of the set follows the market. Where there are many homes, the match gets stricter; where there are few, it loosens, the way a guest gets less picky when there is little to choose from. So a rural set reaches further than a city one.
Dense area
Many homes nearby: a stricter, closer set
Sparse area
Few homes nearby: a looser, wider set
In one worked example from that research, a zero-bedroom private room in downtown San Francisco that sleeps two got a set of 90 homes. They weren't all the same kind: 74 were private rooms and 16 were entire homes or apartments, and some had a bedroom where the room itself had none. The set favored homes close by and also took some further away when their performance was very similar. Pick the five that look most like that room and you'd never see those 16 entire homes.
So price against every home that passes the guest's four checks, not the first five that look alike.
How to build a vacation rental comp set step by step
These steps work in any tool. In Wheelhouse, you do each one in Navigator, our map for building Dynamic Sets.
- Draw the area a guest would search. Start from where your guests want to be, not a fixed radius. In Navigator, draw the boundary on the map.
- Match on what changes the price. Bedrooms and how many guests a home sleeps come first, then the amenities guests pay more for in your season, like a hot tub or a pool. In Navigator, filter by inventory type and amenities.
- Keep homes that price differently from you. A set of homes priced like yours can only tell you your price is right. In Navigator, the pricing filter finds listings that price similarly to you or differently.
- Check that the homes actually book. A listing that rarely books drags the set's numbers down. In Navigator, filter or sort by occupancy, revenue and lead time.
- Choose who you compete with. If you only want to compare with other managers, filter by operator type or portfolio size in Navigator.
- Save it, fixed or updating. A fixed set keeps the same homes. An updating set follows its boundary and filters as homes come and go. In Wheelhouse, save it as a Dynamic Set, which you can lock or change at any time.
Hot tub homes, 3+ bedrooms
Dynamic Set · updates with its filters
- Area
- Drawn on the map
- Inventory type
- Homes
- Bedrooms
- 3+
- Amenities
- Hot tub
- Operator type
- Managers
Filters
- Listings in set
- 38
- Asking rate, open nights
- $412
- Booked rate
- $468
- Occupancy
- 61%
Next 30 days
Once you know what you want, building a Dynamic Set in Navigator takes less than two minutes, and each set costs $12.99 a month.
Vacation rental comp sets when there are few comparable homes
One of our customers wrote to support: "It says my market is Bellingham, WA — that's far from me and I'm a luxury area." A market covers a whole area, so a luxury home or a remote one gets measured against homes its guests would never consider.
Build the set from the homes those guests do weigh against yours. Widen the area first. If that still leaves too few, add homes like yours from other markets: a Dynamic Set can hold listings from several, so a luxury lake house can sit in a set with luxury lake houses elsewhere. That's also our answer when customers ask, "Why don't I get market reports closer to me?" A set's numbers come from the homes you picked.
If Wheelhouse shows a listing as out of market, it isn't in one of the markets we cover yet. Send us a market request through chat, or search for your location on the Markets page.
Can you comp a vacation rental against a hotel?
Yes, when your guests choose between the two. Another customer asked support, "Can you comp me against one specific hotel?" In a city or a resort town, a hotel down the street can be the real alternative for a couple on a short stay.
In Navigator, the inventory type filter includes hotels, so a set can hold hotels next to homes, or hotels on their own. Give them their own set when their rooms are nothing like your homes, so hotel rates don't blur your read on homes.
Asking rate vs booked rate in a vacation rental comp set
A comp set gives you two prices for a night. The asking rate is what a home is listed at for a night that is still open. The booked rate is what a guest paid for a night that sold.
Asking rates on their own mislead. A search for dates leaves out homes that are already booked, so the open homes you see are mostly the ones that haven't sold. Price only against those and you're pricing against the homes guests passed over.
Booked rates have their own catch: a calendar shows a night as unavailable whether a guest booked it or the owner blocked it. We buy listing, pricing and booking data from Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking.com through data partners, and our models estimate whether each unavailable night was booked or blocked.
Read the two side by side. When booked rates sit well above what's still listed, guests are paying more than the leftovers suggest, so don't cut your price to match the open homes. When they sit close, open nights are priced about where guests are booking.
How often to update a vacation rental comp set
Most guides say to review a comp set every quarter, and again when the market changes: new homes open, a rival renovates, the seasons shift. That fits a fixed set you picked by hand.
An updating set keeps its own list current, so your review is about the rules. Is the area still where your guests search? Do the filters still match what changes your price? Check the rules each season, and lock a set when you need the same homes for a before-and-after comparison.
Build your first comp set in Wheelhouse
Draw the area, set the filters and save it as a Dynamic Set. Then price against the homes your guests compare you with.